Real Self-Defense Cases: Why the Right Legal Team Makes All the Difference
These cases show why having the right legal team changes everything.
No matter how cautious or well-trained you are, a self-defense incident can unfold instantly. It could be someone trying to break into your home in the middle of the night, a stranger who becomes aggressive in a parking lot, or even a road-rage encounter that turns violent before you can react. When a self-defense incident occurs, what happens next depends on your actions and the legal team behind you.
Regardless of the circumstances, one thing remains constant: once the incident ends, the legal battle begins. Even if your actions are lawful, the police may still arrest you, and prosecutors may charge you. Additionally, civil lawsuits may follow. In such uncertain circumstances, you need proven self-defense attorneys who can defend your freedom, finances, and peace of mind — even after a completely justified act of self-defense.
At Attorneys On Retainer (AOR), we provide responsible firearm owners with genuine legal protection. Every AOR member is backed by the experienced trial attorneys at The Attorneys For Freedom Law Firm (AFF), the only law firm in the nation focused exclusively on self-defense.
These real-life cases illustrate the challenges ordinary people face in extraordinary circumstances, highlighting how being an AOR member provides access to a dedicated legal team ready to defend their freedom and future.
Prescott, Arizona: Arrested for Lawful Defensive Display
Matthew Massucci, a responsible gun owner living in Prescott, Arizona, was arrested after a defensive display of his firearm during a confrontation outside a convenience store. When an aggressive man blocked his car door, Matthew retrieved his legally owned firearm from his center console and held it in a low, non-threatening position to protect himself.
Despite having no criminal record, he was taken into custody during a high-risk felony stop and charged with multiple felonies. His first attorney told him the case had been dropped, but prosecutors refiled the charges months later. Realizing he still faced serious accusations, Matthew turned to the Attorneys For Freedom Law Firm, whose team obtained surveillance footage, brought in a forensic video expert, and proved the allegations were false. All charges were dismissed.
Because Matthew was not an Attorneys On Retainer (AOR) member, he paid thousands in legal fees and lost income. Had he been a member, his entire defense would have been covered.
Key Takeaway: Even a lawful defensive display can result in arrest and criminal charges. An AOR membership alleviates financial stress and provides immediate access to a skilled legal defense team.
Portland, Oregon: No Charges After a Self-Defense Shooting
Eric Salisbury, a licensed security professional, was on duty at a Jewish preschool in Portland when a serious threat arose. A violent altercation occurred, and in self-defense, he drew his firearm to stop the attack. Mr. Salisbury had immediate access to our legal team as an AOR member. His AFF attorneys guided him through every step of the process and played a vital role in the prosecutors’ decision not to bring charges.
No one expects to face an armed threat, but self-defense incidents can happen anywhere. With AOR, you’ll have experienced self-defense attorneys available 24/7/365, no matter where you are.
Key Takeaway: In a moment of crisis, a single call to AOR connects you directly with experienced legal counsel, ready to defend your rights.
New York: Attempted Murder Charge Dismissed in a Gun-Free Zone
In New York, one of the states with the most restrictive firearm laws in the nation, an AOR member acted to protect his life in a gun-free zone. He faced an attempted murder charge and the possibility of years in prison, complicated by the fact that his firearm was not registered in the state.
Our AOR team immediately intervened. Working with local counsel, we built a strong defense that proved his actions were lawful and necessary. After months of litigation, the attempted murder charge was dismissed.
Key Takeaway: Anyone can face significant legal risks under restrictive state laws. AOR’s nationwide coverage protects you, even where carrying is heavily regulated.
Armed Robbery: Member Cleared After Acting in Self-Defense
During an armed robbery, an AOR member was forced to use his firearm in self-defense. After the police arrived, he was detained and questioned before prosecutors reviewed the case. Fortunately, his dashcam recorded the entire incident, which provided clear evidence that his actions were justified. The footage proved his innocence and ensured he faced no charges.
As an AOR member, he did not have to worry about finding or paying for an attorney. Our team immediately coordinated with local counsel and investigators while advocating for him at every step. The member faced no charges, and his firearm rights were fully preserved.
Key Takeaway: While video evidence can be powerful, having immediate legal representation ensures any relevant evidence is utilized effectively to strengthen your defense.
It Can Happen to Anyone
The common theme in these stories is unpredictability. All of these individuals were adequately trained and acted responsibly, yet in an instant, they needed to defend themselves. These stories are actual experiences from real people. This is what sets AOR apart. We provide trusted legal protection for responsible gun owners, self-defense advocates, and anyone who values the right to protect themselves or others.
*Disclaimer: Attorneys On Retainer is not an insurance company. Coverage applies only to qualifying self-defense incidents defined in the AOR Membership Agreement. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes. Laws vary by jurisdiction, and readers should consult with a qualified attorney regarding their specific situation.*
